Prepaid vs Pay-As-You-Go Subscriptions: Which to Offer
Prepaid takes cash up front and removes mid-term churn. Pay-as-you-go converts better. How to choose between them, and why offering both usually wins.
| Pay as you go | Prepaid | |
|---|---|---|
| Cash arrives | Each cycle | Up front |
| Checkout conversion | Higher — small ask | Lower — big ask |
| Churn mid-term | Every cycle is a decision | None during the term |
| Renewal can fail | Every cycle | Once, at the end |
| Best for | Trying the product | Customers who already love it |
Every subscription plan makes one structural choice before any of the others: does the customer pay per delivery, or pay once for many deliveries?
Pay-as-you-go
Bill each cycle as it ships.
Converts better. The commitment at checkout is one delivery’s worth of money. For a $30 box, the customer is agreeing to $30 today, not $180.
Churn is continuous. Every cycle is a decision point, and some proportion of subscribers exit at each one.
Cash arrives slowly, which matters if you are buying inventory ahead of demand.
Renewals can fail. Each one is a fresh payment that can decline — an expired card, a thin week, or an issuer asking the customer to authenticate.
Prepaid
Take payment for N deliveries at once.
Cash now. You have the money before you buy the stock, which is a materially different working-capital position.
Near-zero churn during the term. There is no monthly decision point because there is no monthly charge. The subscriber is committed through the paid period.
Higher LTV per signup, usually — even at a bigger discount, six guaranteed deliveries typically beat the expected value of a monthly plan that churns.
Converts worse. The checkout ask is much larger. Expect fewer signups.
Renewal is a cliff. At the end of the prepaid term the customer makes one big decision rather than six small ones. Prepaid renewal needs its own reminder sequence starting well before the term ends.
The payment reason prepaid matters
Every renewal on a pay-as-you-go plan is a new charge, and every new charge can fail.
Prepaid takes one payment at checkout — where the customer is present, authenticated and expecting to pay — and then schedules deliveries against money already collected. For the whole prepaid term there is no renewal to decline, no expired card to chase and no authentication request to go unanswered.
For high-value plans that removes an entire category of involuntary churn. Why subscription payments fail.
Discounting prepaid
Prepaid should carry a bigger discount than pay-as-you-go, because the customer is giving you money early and accepting commitment risk.
A common structure:
| Plan | Discount | What you get |
|---|---|---|
| One-time | 0% | Nothing |
| Monthly, pay as you go | 10% | Repeat revenue, monthly churn |
| 3 months prepaid | 15% | Quarter of cash up front |
| 6 months prepaid | 20% | Half a year committed |
The discount ladder should reflect the value of the commitment, and the steps should be visible next to each other so the customer can see the trade they are making.
Offer both
They are not competing options; they suit different customers. Someone trying your product wants pay-as-you-go. Someone who already loves it and wants the best price wants prepaid.
On Shopify these are two selling plan groups on the same product, presented as two choices. Nothing stops you offering both, and offering both usually beats picking one.
Operationally
Prepaid demands more discipline:
- Deliveries are an obligation, not a revenue event. You have been paid; every delivery after that is cost. Forecast it.
- Refunds are messier. A cancellation mid-term means calculating the value of undelivered cycles and issuing a partial refund — with a credit note where your tax rules require one.
- Renewal needs a runway. Start reminding four to six weeks before the term ends.
Prepaid plans are on Super Subscription’s roadmap; today the app runs pay-as-you-go subscriptions. See what is available now.
Questions people ask
- What is a prepaid subscription?
- The customer pays once for a set number of deliveries — say six months up front — and those deliveries are then scheduled without further charges. Billing happens once; delivery happens many times.
Part of the guide to How to Add Subscriptions to Your Shopify Store.